Employment Hero vs OnPay

Take a look at how Employment Hero and OnPay stack up against each other across pricing, features, and support using feedback from real users like yourself. Employment Hero scores 4.5 out of 5 from 137 reviews, while OnPay has been rated 4.8 out of 5 from 273 reviews.
Share
Advertising disclosure: Findstack offers objective, editorially independent comparisons to help you find the best software. Some links on this page are affiliate links — we may earn a commission when you visit a vendor through our links, at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships never influence our ratings, rankings, or reviews. Disclosure policy | Methodology
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo

Employment Hero

4.5

( 137 )

OnPay Payroll Software logo

OnPay

4.8

( 273 )

Start selling digital products with Crevio
Crevio E-Commerce Platforms logo
Crevio
Sponsored
5.0
(1)
Free plan available
Crevio is an AI-powered platform that runs your business while you sleep. Describe what you want to se... Learn more about Crevio
At a Glance
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Starting at:
$19.00/month
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
Starting at:
$2.00/month
Overview
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Employment Hero is a comprehensive cloud-based platform designed to simplify and automate human resources (HR), payroll, and employee engagement processes for businesses of all sizes. It offers a suite of tools that cover the entire employee lifecycle, from recruitment and onboarding to performan... Learn more
Capabilities
  • AI Enabled
  • API Available
  • Open Source
  • CLI Available
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
OnPay is a cloud-based, full-service payroll system for U.S. businesses (especially small & medium). It integrates payroll, HR tools, benefits, worker compliance, and time-tracking integrations; handles federal, state, and local payroll taxes; supports W-2 employees and 1099 contractors; offers u... Learn more
Capabilities
  • AI Enabled
  • API Available
  • Open Source
  • CLI Available
Exclusive Deals
Discover Amazing Software Deals on Findstack
Get access to up to $900,000+ in savings on the best software to scale your business.
Pricing
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Free trial available
Free plan available
Billing type Recurring Subscription
Lite
$19.00
/ month
Plus
$29.00
/ month
Unlimited
$49.00
/ month
See all pricing
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
Free trial available
Free plan available
Billing type Usage Based
HR Add-On - per employee
$2.00
/ month
Base (Payroll) - per employee
$6.00
/ month
Direct mail - year-end forms (optional)
$10.00
one-time
HR Add-On - base
$15.00
/ month
Base (Payroll) - base fee
$49.00
/ month
See all pricing
Pros and Cons
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Pros
  • Comprehensive all-in-one HR and payroll solution
  • User-friendly interface with intuitive navigation
  • Scalable pricing plans suitable for businesses of various sizes
  • Integration with popular accounting and productivity tools
  • Regular updates and feature enhancements
Cons
  • Pricing may be higher compared to some competitors
  • Certain advanced features require higher-tier plans
  • Limited customization options in lower-tier plans
  • Potential learning curve for users new to HR software
  • Customer support response times can vary
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
Pros
  • Transparent, simple pricing (flat base fee + per-employee) with most features included
  • Unlimited pay runs and multi-state payroll without extra fees
  • Integrated workers' compensation and benefits broker support
  • Strong customer support and tax accuracy guarantee
  • Lifetime employee access to pay stubs and year-end tax forms
Cons
  • No built-in time-tracking (requires third-party integrations)
  • No clear public mobile apps for administrators (mobile app status unclear)
  • HR features are add-ons and may increase cost for larger headcounts
  • Not open-source; no public CLI tool
Reviewer's Segments
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Small Business
58.39%
Mid Market
41.61%
Enterprise
0.0%
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
Small Business
97.8%
Mid Market
2.2%
Enterprise
0.0%
Deployment
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
  • Cloud based
  • Desktop based
  • Mobile based
  • On-premise
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
  • Cloud based
  • Desktop based
  • Mobile based
  • On-premise
Support
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
  • 24/7 (Live rep)
  • Chat
  • Email/Help Desk
  • FAQs/Forum
  • Knowledge Base
  • Phone Support
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
  • 24/7 (Live rep)
  • Chat
  • Email/Help Desk
  • FAQs/Forum
  • Knowledge Base
  • Phone Support
Training
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
  • Documentation
  • Webinars
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
  • Documentation
  • Webinars
Integrations
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
Total integrations: 3
  • Deputy
  • PARiM
  • QuickBooks Online
  • Slack
  • TurboTax
  • Xero
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
Total integrations: 4
  • Deputy
  • PARiM
  • QuickBooks Online
  • Slack
  • TurboTax
  • Xero
Top Alternatives
Employment Hero Payroll Software logo
Employment Hero
See all alternatives
OnPay Payroll Software logo
OnPay
See all alternatives